EVERY great leader wrestles with the same paradox: How do I inspire long-term vision while driving day to day results?
This tension sits at the crossroads of two leadership styles — transformational and transactional. Each has its strengths. Each serves a purpose.
But when one dominates unchecked, the organisation either drifts into lofty ideas without traction or grinds into routine without renewal.
To lead effectively especially in fast changing, high stakes environments like Zimbabwe’s business climate or global mission driven ventures, you must manage the space between transformation and transaction.
Transformational leadership is a leadership style that focuses on empowering employees with skills to achieve desired results through vision and motivation.
Transformal leadership focuses on:
- Vision and purpose
Transformational leaders are charismatic in nature and they have the flair of connecting with all stakeholders in the organisation.
Notably one of their key strengths is effective communication.
- Australia floods worsen as thousands more flee Sydney homes
- In the groove: Chiwoniso Maraire remembered
- Bosso search for elusive away win
- DYNAMOS coach Tonderai Ndiraya has backed his misfiring strikers to start banging the goals soon.
Keep Reading
They have the ability to clearly articulate the core tenants of their vision and purpose of the company in order to enable every team-member to align and be compelled to work towards the attainment of the collective goal for the organisation.
- Innovation and change
Most organisations task transformational leaders to play a key role in driving organisational change and innovation.
They leverage their expertise to guide and assist team-members navigate through phases of change by providing clarity and support which leads to successful implementation of strategies and processes.
They encourage creativity and innovation by challenging the status quo and promoting strategic thinking.
They encourage continuous improvement among team members so as to strategically position themselves for change and innovation.
Inspiring followers to exceed expectations.
They are endowed with special skills to inspire their team members to work to expected standards.
They emotionally connect with their followers enabling them to strive for excellence.
Personal and professional growth
Transformational leaders recognise the unique strengths and needs of each team member.
Notably they provide personalised support and mentorship, creating an environment where everyone feels valued and empowered to grow.
Most importantly, they inspire the teams to put more effort so as to achieve set organisational goals.
On the other hand, transactional leadership style is a management style that focuses on structured tasks, rewards and penalties to motivate followers to achieve set goals.
Moreover, this type of leadership is characterised by a clear structure and clear roles within an organisation.
Transactional leadership focuses on:
Structure and discipline
This leadership style strives in environments that require strict adherence to rules and procedures.
They also provide clear guidelines and expectations which enhance productivity and efficiency.
Such leaders maintain the status quo, organisational structure, performance and outcomes.
Roles, tasks and rewards
Leaders set specific goals and expectations for their team members.
Performance is managed through a rewards system such as salaries, bonuses, accolades and corrective action e.g. reprimands.
The leader views the relationship between managers and subordinates as a transaction; workers carry out the delegated tasks in return they are rewarded with a salary.
Transactional leaders are tasked to effectively communicate organisational/ team expectations.
Meeting performance metrics
When subordinates perform well, they receive a reward such as a salary, however, when they perform poorly at times they will be subjected to verbal warnings, written warnings or performance improvement plans.
Maintaining consistency
Transactional leaders do so by driving a rigorous agenda.
For instance, their meetings tend to be structured around an agenda with clear action points.
They would usually pose the following questions at the start of their meetings: What is our intention for this meeting? What is important? What matters?
This type of leader has a very direct communication style.
Their instructions are straightforward and matter of fact.
They are really big on creating standard operating or reporting formats, to ensure a uniform flow information throughout the business.
Why does the tension matter?
It matters because people need both inspiration and clarity to find the balance of discipline in systems, processes and accountability — with structure, rigour and goals.
Good leaders tend to be really good at knowing when to leverage a particular leadership style to suit the situation in front of them.
The most effective leaders navigate the vision-execution paradox through disciplined self-awareness and intentional adaptation.
This begins with honest assessment: are you naturally inclined toward transformational thinking (the big picture architect) or transactional execution (the detail-driven implementer)?
Research from the Harvard Business Review reveals that 72% of leaders exhibit a natural preference for one style over the other, creating organisational blind spots.
Remember: Vision without execution is hallucination. Execution without vision is stagnation.
The leader’s ultimate task is to be bilingual — fluent in both transformational inspiration and transactional precision, knowing when to shift between these modes as circumstances demand.
Balancing vision with execution is not a one-time act; it is a daily discipline. The role of the leader is to continually adjust, ensuring neither the dream nor the discipline dominates at the expense of the other.
That is where true and lasting impact is found.
- IInnocent Hadebe, with 25 years of experience and credentials as a John Maxwell certified business coach, serves as a trusted executive advisor through Innocent Leadership Group (ILG), empowering global leaders to think boldly, lead transformational change and turn operational complexity into measurable success
